I'm not the greatest at applying eyeliner, I have always had a hard time making a good line. I use pencil eyeliner, because liquid eyeliner is kind of hard for me to use. I picked this up for $1 and figured I would give it a try. I like it, it wasn't as hard to use as other ones I have tried. It lasted all day, but my only complaint is that it was shinny all day, it looked almost wet, I like matte eyeliners, so this was not what I was looking for.